Skip to content

Exumas Cays: The Galapagos Islands’ Quirky Sister?

This post contains affiliate links to trusted partners. If you purchase through these links, I earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you!

swimming pigs
Swimming pigs at Big Major Spot

I can feel freckles forming on my nose as the sun paints my face with its rays.

Translucent blue waters showcase vibrant tropical fish and colorful corals, while white sand beaches provide the perfect place for an afternoon picnic.

All around me it’s a Caribbean paradise of palms, shells, sailboats, and … swimming pigs?

David and Christina, owners of the Staniel Cay Yacht Club, have offered to take my friends and I out on their boat for a day of exploring the Exuma Cays in the Bahamas.

The Exumas are a group of 365 cays (only 29 are inhabited) in the Bahamas, located about 30 minutes by plane from Nassau.

While Nassau is home to big resorts and trendy restaurants, the Exumas have a much more laid-back vibe, the type of place where some inhabited cays only have one local restaurant and everyone knows each others’ name.

It’s apparently also a place with some crazy quirky offerings, as I didn’t even know pigs could swim, let alone inhabit their own private island. But here at Big Major Spot, enormous wild pigs come darting out of the island forest like desert nomads in desperate need of a cool down.

“People brought them to the island along with goats and chickens,” explains David. “They’ve gotten used to people feeding them so they swim to the boats.”

Sure enough, soon there are pigs anxiously circling the boat. How do I react? I jump in to swim with them, of course.

The pigs prove to be harmless, and as long as you don’t touch them they allow you to get close enough for some photo opportunities. It’s fun to watch them swim and play fight with each other. Not to mention I can now check swimming with pigs off my bucket list.

shark sign
Swim with sharks at your own risk…

From there our tour takes us to Compass Cay, where we meet Tucker and see his impressive collection of painted driftwood signs. Apparently, boaters and visitors will decorate and donate them to leave a piece of themselves behind on the beautiful cay.

As I’m admiring the signs, something stirring in the water catches my eye. At first I think I’m hallucinating, until I see the distinct fins of the ocean’s most carnivorous predator and the Jaws theme song begins playing in my head.

“Ready to swim?” asks David, who’s holding a bloody piece of fish. He throws the meat into the water and instantly the sharks begin swarming, their heads coming out of the water for a closer look.

Davd informs me that these are Nurse Sharks, and that there’s never “been an incident.” While this is comforting, I remind myself I don’t have the best luck, and I wouldn’t be surprised if I become their first incident.

Despite everything, I’m also the type of person who’s biggest fear is regret, and I know if I don’t swim with these enormous sharp-finned creatures I will regret it.

“On the count of three. One. Two. Thr…”

Swimming with Nurse Sharks at Compass Cay

I’m in. The water is refreshing, although I’m not sure what’s around me because I’m clenching my eyes closed. I feel a splash, some sand and then… a giant fin. When I open my eyes I’m surrounded by maybe 30 Nurse Sharks, although they’re aggressively going for the chum and not my appendages (which I’m thankful for). I’m not sure they have the best vision though, as they keep smashing into me as they frantically swim toward the cut up Mahi Mahi David has thrown into the water.

Swim with sharks and not get eaten? Check!

Next we’re off to do something one can only do in the Exumas: go snorkeling in James Bonds’ hidden underwater lair. Thunderball Grotto is where the James Bond movies Never Say Never Again and Thunderball were filmed. To get inside the grotto you’ll need to pass under a low cave opening — so small you wouldn’t know it was there unless someone told you. Once inside, the cavern opens up to reveal a world of sea-urchin embedded limestone, dangling plants and tropical fish. The mysterious world is illuminated only by a tire-sized opening at the top, making it feel like I’m inside a water-filled volcano. I spot sergeant majors, angelfish and blue tangs in the water, which is so clear you barely need a mask. James Bond sure had good taste.

Iguanas on Bitter Guana Cay

At our last stop for the day I become convinced the Exumas are the Galapagos of the Caribbean. We’re at Bitter Guana Cay, and from afar it almost appears like there are wild cats running around the island. Upon closer inspection, however, I realize they are giant iguanas.

“People say they arrived to the island on floating logs,” explains David.

They run around chasing each other frantically along the beach; however, as my group walks onto the sand they all seem to freeze. Suddenly, an iguana about three times the size of the rest storms out of the high grass, and the small ones call to attention. The alpha-guana begins moving them around, probably trying to get them away from the strange alien forms that have just descended onto the beach; however, soon they start to become comfortable with us, even approaching as if to say hello (although the fact that I’m holding a fruit cup probably doesn’t hurt).

By the end of the day I’m convinced the Exumas are the quirkiest island destination in the world.

Where else can you wade in crystal waters surrounded by glistening palms and white powder beaches while also swimming with pigs, jumping into a pit of sharks, visiting the lair of the world’s most iconic Secret Service Agent and frolicking on a beach of enormous iguanas with the intelligence of European explorers?

Nowhere but the Exumas.

Whether you’re traveling in a group or on a solo Caribbean vacation, you should definitely add the Exumas to your bucket list.

Have you ever had a quirky island experience? Please share in the comments below.

*My trip to the Exumas Cays was sponsored by the Bahamas Tourism Board. I was not required to write this article nor was I compensated in any way. All opinions are my own.

About Jessie Festa

Jessie Festa is a New York-based travel content creator who is passionate about empowering her audience to experience new places and live a life of adventure. She is the founder of the solo female travel blog, Jessie on a Journey, and is editor-in-chief of Epicure & Culture, an online conscious tourism magazine. Along with writing, Jessie is a professional photographer and is the owner of NYC Photo Journeys, which offers New York photo tours, photo shoots, and wedding photography. Her work has appeared in publications like USA Today, CNN, Business Insider, Thrillist, and WestJet Magazine.

Jessie Festa standing in front of grafitti wall

Hi, I’m Jessie on a journey!

I'm a conscious solo traveler on a mission to take you beyond the guidebook to inspire you to live your best life through travel. Come join me!

Blogging Courses

Want to live your best life through travel?

Subscribe for FREE access to my library of fun blogging worksheets and learn how to get paid to travel more!



  1. Jodi on at 12:21 pm

    Those swimming pigs are so unexpected! Thanks for introducing me to the Exumas Cays, as I’ve never heard of them before now. Happy travels!

    • jess2716 on at 1:26 pm

      @Jodi- It’s a great destination with a lot to offer. I highly recommend it! 🙂

  2. Karin-Marijke Vis on at 4:59 pm

    I have never heard of this place. It sounds quite intriguing! Thanks for sharing.

    • jess2716 on at 9:17 pm

      @Karin-Marijke: Definitely unlike any other place I’ve ever visited in the Caribbean! ha.

  3. Kurtis R. Newton on at 11:57 am

    We finally arrived back in Great Exuma about 10 hours after we left. It was a long but very fulfilling trip. It’s not inexpensive (priced at about $375 per person) but it’s one of the most enjoyable experiences I’ve had in the Caribbean and Bahamas. High-speed boats, iguanas, swimming pigs, sharks and a cave famous for a James Bond movie. I mean, what could be a better day!

Leave a Comment